Patmeena Sabit. Good People. USA: Random House Large Print, 2026.
Here’s an innovative style that takes the reader on an extended trip into territory experienced by Afghan refugees as they settled in Virginia, USA. An unknown event of significance has taken place among them and although we have no inkling, the police have collected statements and interviews regarding the Sharaf family. In a most effective way, the communications describe family personalities and draw us into the community’s culture. Friends and neighbours of the family were not necessarily in accord on all details. Adding to the natural tone of the interviews are untranslated common idiomatic expressions in their language – a very credible touch. About one-third of the way in, the shocking main incident is revealed (moi trying hard not to be a spoiler) and the outrage begins. All the way to the investigators’ inconclusive analyses.
Husband and father Rahmat is a hard-working, ambitious guy who builds a prosperous business from poor beginnings; wife and mother Maryam, of a more educated class, is loving, efficient, and cheerful; the older children Omer and Zorah are devoted to each other as best friends. Our story covers the time from the birth of those two, to their teenage years, complete with school, friends, and family expectations—presented in an engaging, subtly powerful manner. As police and media reports try to reconstruct the last day the family was known to be together, conflicting views of the characters emerge; the incident itself has more than one interpretation.
Kudos to author Sabit for such an impressive first novel. It appeals to an audience well beyond crime fiction. If some readers heard a bell ringing from old headlines, now you will know everything there is to know.
Parents
▪ The big problem with Sharaf—the entire issue—was that he wanted to swallow the whole world in one gulp, and he thought all he had to do was figure out how to open his mouth wide enough. (22)
▪ Not that he was a miser. He didn’t begrudge his wife and children anything. (96)
▪ They loved taking little trips. Sharaf always took them where they could learn something. To museums and things like that. (98)
▪ “Work work work,” I said. “There’s nothing else in the world for you people. When are you going to enjoy yourselves?” (123)
▪ They forgot who they were. They tried to be what they weren’t. They became more American than the Americans. (149)
▪ “Before I let you have her, I’ll kill her myself.” (384)
Children
▪ Omer wasn’t like a boy grown up here. He was so gentle, so polite. Small with children and mature with adults. A character of pure gold. (105)
Zorah was the light of the house. The very top of Maryam’s and Sharaf’s hearts. She was the joker, the one who pranked and teased everyone. (105)
▪ I’m telling you, this teenage girl had a closet as big as an apartment for all her clothes and shoes and purses. (142)
▪ She told them she hated school. She didn’t want to be a lawyer or a judge. That was boring. She wanted to be a makeup artist. (190)
▪ This horrible thing they did to save their own child was they grounded her. (234)
▪ “I was willing to overlook her rot and stink and take her into my home to cover your great shame.” (375)
Kathy Reichs. A Conspiracy of Bones. Toronto: Simon & Schuster Canada, 2020.
Forensic anthropologist Tempe Brennan is troubled. Pathologist Margot Heavner was promoted to County Medical Examiner and she refuses to call regular consultant Tempe for any autopsy cases. In the past, Heavner’s personal ambitions crossed some ethical lines that Tempe criticized; disclosing personal details of cold case victims is a no-no. Especially to a hardline conspiracy theorist like blogger Nick Body. Now, a male body at hand has a ruined face and hands, therefore identity unknown. Determined to pursue and solve the matter on her own, Tempe has the grudging support of ex-cop Skinny Slidell but not the least of her anxieties is the aneurysm she’s recently been treated for.
From the slimmest of clues, Tempe finds people who interacted with the mystery man, naming him Felix Vodyanov. The clues multiply but make little sense, full of complicated codes, calling up memories of children’s cold cases and referencing dark web conspiracies. I had to speed-read through pages of commonly-held and not so common nutbar theories, Tempe glued to her laptop when not rashly charging alone into one apprehensive situation after another. Was Felix a Russian agent? A child abuser? Why are people secretively buying underground real estate? Is the aneurysm giving Tempe delusions, or is she merely paranoid? The story becomes an endless litany of Tempe’s questions.
So dense with obsession and self-reflection, the plot bogs down for me. Disappointing. Although Reich’s touch with dialogue stays fresh and humorous. To be fair, the author’s afterword reveals that much of the novel’s content is autobiographical.
Bits
▪ Heavener’s disclosure about Hardin Symes was improper and callous. She hurt Hardin’s family. She compromised the prosecution of his killer. (23)
▪ “Do you seriously think this office cannot function without you, Dr. Brennan? That I am incapable of determining when specialty expertise is required?” (28)
▪ “One thing stuck with me. Once, he said his life would soon be over.” (109)
▪ “But I swear to God I seen a kid peering out the rear window. A small little face with a tiny hand to either side.” (127)
▪ Did this recent recklessness arise from a newborn sense of my own mortality? One day, the aneurysm may burst, so what the hell? (187)
▪ Some of his rants were more toxic than I’d imagined. Over the past decade, Body had been particularly vehement on two themes. Plots involving kids. Plots involving medical wrongdoing. (254)







